Why Is It Called The Brunner Test
Named for the case in which it was first used, Brunner v. New York Higher Education Services Corp., the Brunner test is a three-part system used to determine whether or not a debtor is suffering from undue hardship, and cannot make student loan payments as a result.
The Brunner test is a complicated and often confusing process, and using it to establish undue hardship can be quite difficult. What makes things particularly confusing is that the Bankruptcy Code fails to actually define undue hardship, leaving this decision up to the courts.
The so-called âBrunner Ruleâ states that student loan debts are only dischargeable under extreme, and very specific, conditions. Although proving undue hardship under the Brunner rule can be difficult, partial discharges on student loans are more common. In some cases, student loan borrowers will be denied any discharge of federal or private student loans, but will be granted a lower interest rate, deferment, or an extension on the repayment period of student loans.
Consult With A Bankruptcy Attorney
The Brunner Test and other standards are often applied to Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 debtors in many court cases. If you have a considerable amount of student loan debt, its wise to meet with a local bankruptcy attorney. If you decide to appeal the discharge issue in bankruptcy court, youll want an attorney to represent you. Groce & DeArmon, P.C. are the bankruptcy attorneys you can trust. Contact us today so you can get off to a fresh start.
Feb Unlocking The Secret Of Discharging Student Loans In Chapter 7 Bankruptcy
It seems as if everyone owes money on student loans. With the high cost of education its a given that most Americans need some financial assistance when it comes to schooling. So if you have student loans outstanding, at least you can take comfort in the fact that youre not alone.
Will Chapter 7 bankruptcy wipe out your student loans? Without sounding too much like a lawyer, the answer depends on the facts of your individual situation.
No matter what happens, those student loans arent going to disappear in your Chapter 7 bankruptcy without a lot of work and headaches.
The gold standard in many bankruptcy courts stems from a New York bankruptcy case calledBrunner vs. New York State Higher Education Services Corp., 831 F.2d 395 .
You dont need to know the formal citation for the decision, but the 3-part roadmap it sets out for discharging student loans in Chapter 7 bankruptcy is invaluable.
UnderBrunner, youve got to satisfy three conditions in order to discharge your student loans in a Chapter 7 bankruptcy.
Image credit:architekt2/Flickr
Also Check: How Many Times Has Trump Filed For Bankrupsy
Talk To A Bankruptcy Lawyer
Need professional help? Start here.
Self-help services may not be permitted in all states. The information provided on this site is not legal advice, does not constitute a lawyer referral service, and no attorney-client or confidential relationship is or will be formed by use of the site. The attorney listings on this site are paid attorney advertising. In some states, the information on this website may be considered a lawyer referral service. Please reference the Terms of Use and the Supplemental Terms for specific information related to your state. Your use of this website constitutes acceptance of the Terms of Use, Supplemental Terms, Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy. Do Not Sell My Personal Information
Stop A Foreclosure Repossession Or Eviction
The automatic stay will stop these actions as long as they’re still pending. Once complete, bankruptcy won’t help.
- Evictions. An eviction that’s still in the litigation process will come to a halt after a bankruptcy filing. But the stay will likely be temporary. Keep in mind that if your landlord already has an eviction judgment against you, bankruptcy won’t help in the majority of states. Learn more about evictions and the automatic stay.
- Foreclosure and repossession. Although the automatic stay will stop a foreclosure or repossession, filing for Chapter 7 won’t help you keep the property. If you can’t bring the account current, you’ll lose the house or car once the stay lifts. By contrast, Chapter 13 has a mechanism that will allow you to catch up on past payments so you can keep the asset. Find out more about bankruptcy’s automatic stay and foreclosure and car repossession and bankruptcy.
Also Check: How Many Bankruptcies Has Donald Trump Filed
Bankruptcy And Student Loan Debt
In most cases, student debts cannot be discharged in bankruptcy, but there is one exception.
Student loan debt will not be discharged in most Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy cases. If you can show that repaying your student loans will cause you undue hardship, you may be able to discharge them in bankruptcy.
Recommended Reading: Can Restitution Be Included In Bankruptcy
Does Conway Set A New Precedent
In the case of Conway v. National Collegiate Trust, the Eight Circuit Court recently ruled that Ms. Conway should be granted permission to seek discharges of about 20 separate private student loans, loans with a combined total balance of well over $100,000 in total debt.
Conway graduated from a well-renowned school with a B.A. in Writing, and was able to find full-time work in the field, but was then laid off from two different jobs between her graduation and 2008.
As a response to her major economic troubles, she filed for bankruptcy protection, requesting to have her private student loans discharged in the process.
Two of her private lenders agreed, but a third company called the National Collegiate Trust , contested the initial court ruling.
At the time of the dispute, Ms. Conway had a total of 15 loans from NCT, which carried a total balance of $118,579.66 .
Recommended Reading: Can Bankruptcy Wipe Out A Judgement
How To Prove Undue Hardship For Student Loans
To discharge student loans via bankruptcy, you will have to prove they pose an undue hardship during your adversary proceeding.
The U.S. Bankruptcy Code doesnt define undue hardship, so bankruptcy courts have different interpretations for its meaning. Most use whats known as the Brunner test to determine whether bankruptcy filers student loans meet the undue hardship standard.
You must prove that you meet all three parts of the Brunner test to get your college debt discharged:
1. Making student loan payments would keep you from maintaining a minimal standard of living based on your current income and expenses. To meet this, you generally must have bare-bones expenses and must have done everything in your power to increase your income, without success.
2. Additional circumstances make it very likely that your financial situation will persist for a significant portion of your remaining loan period. Among other things, you may be able to successfully meet this if you have a serious mental or physical disability, received a poor-quality education or have maximized your income potential in your field.
3. Youve made “good faith” efforts to repay your loans. You may meet this prong by making some loan payments, attempting to negotiate a payment plan and working to slash unnecessary expenses and increase income.
Different jurisdictions and judges have different interpretations of these standards so your outcome will depend on your location and the judge you get.
Court Allows Bankruptcy Discharge Of $200000 In Student Loans
Getty
A new ruling by a U.S. appeals court has affirmed the cancellation of a borrowers $200,000 in private student loans.
In McDaniel v. Navient, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit affirmed a lower bankruptcy courts determination that a borrowers private student loan debt could be discharged in bankruptcy.
The bankruptcy code treats student loan debt differently from most other forms of consumer debt, such as credit cards and medical bills. Borrowers must generally prove that they have an undue hardship in order to discharge their student loan debt in bankruptcy. These restrictions initially only applied to federal student loans, but were subsequently expanded to cover private student loans following the passage of a 2005 bankruptcy reform bill.
The recent ruling from the 10th Circuit could change this.
The borrower in the case had taken out $120,000 in private student loans. When she became unable to afford the monthly payments, she said that Navient would not work with her to provide an affordable repayment schedule . She eventually went into bankruptcy. After her bankruptcy ended, Navient added on tens of thousands of dollars in additional interest, leaving her in an even worse position and causing her to pay even more money to Navient. She ultimately then petitioned the bankruptcy court to reopen the bankruptcy case to rule that the private student loans were, or should have been, discharged.
Recommended Reading: Bankruptcy Case Closed Without Discharge
Lawmakers Call For Investigation After Npr Report On Troubled Student Loan Program
Iuliano says the outcome and how much student debt is forgiven, if any, can have a lot to do with what particular judge you end up with and what the rules are in that bankruptcy district.
Some of that is because of the language of the original statute stating that student loan borrowers have to meet a threshold of undue hardship, he says. Iuliano says Congress has never defined what that means, so a lot of discretion is left up to the courts and the particular judge you get.
Harrison Wadsworth, a consultant for the Consumer Bankers Association, notes that most student loans are issued by the government. But for loans from private lenders, he says relaxing the bankruptcy rules to make it easier to reduce or eliminate student debt could push up interest rates. Lenders would have to be careful about making loans and probably have to charge more for them, Wadsworth says.
Lauren eventually found a lawyer who took her case and charged her about $3,000, doing some of the work pro bono. And going through bankruptcy, she got her debt reduced from about $200,000 to around $100,000, with the bulk of that reduced to a 1% interest rate.
Can You File Bankruptcy On Student Loans
Being overwhelmed by debt that seems insurmountable is not an easy place to be.
If you are in student loan debt and are also thinking about bankruptcy, its important to learn about your options and not give up hope.
Getting student loan debt discharged in bankruptcy is difficult, but not impossible. In fact, student loans may be dischargeable if they cause undue hardship.
Read Also: How Many Times Has Trump Filed Bankruptcies
Can I Discharge My Student Loans In Bankruptcy
- If you skip payments or default on a student loan, you can seriously damage your credit.
- Know the basics of your student loans, including how and when you must repay them, and how you can get help if you run into trouble with repayment.
- If you have certain kinds of student loans, you may qualify for a repayment plan that sets payment amounts based on your current income.
- Student Loan Forgiveness Progams Did you work full time in a public service job for at least 10 years? Did you make payments on your direct student loan for that entire time? If so, you may be able to get ALL of your remaining student loan debt cancelled once you’ve made your 120th qualifying payment.
- The consequences of defaulting on a student loan are serious and long-lasting — and may depend on where you live. Here is information for your state.
- Unfair Student Loan Collection Practices: How to Fight Back When you default on a student loan, you may be subject to a wide range of collection tactics — from phone calls and letters to the loss of your tax refund or some of your wages. Know what’s legal and what’s not.
- If you find yourself facing a student loan lawsuit, don’t panic — but don’t ignore it, either. Here are a few things you should do.
Do Your Student Loans Impose An Undue Hardship
While the bankruptcy code does not explicitly state what qualifies as an undue hardship, courts across the country have done their best to fill in the legislative gaps. Missouri falls in a minority of jurisdictions that use a totality of the circumstances test to determine whether a student loan imposes such a hardship.
The main inquiry of a bankruptcy court for this purpose is to determine whether the debtors future financial resources will allow for any payment of the student loan debt while maintaining a minimal standard of living. If payments can be made while meeting such a minimal standard then the debt is non-dischargeable. The burden will always fall on the individual debtor to prove that they lack the resources to make a payment.
Read Also: How Many Bankruptcies Has Donald Trump Filed
The Brunner Test: Financial Hardship
The Brunner Test is the most common test used among courts. Under this test, you can discharge your loan if you meet three factors: poverty, persistence, and good faith. Poverty refers to your current income and expenses. You meet this factor if you cannot maintain a minimal standard of living for yourself and for your family if you repay your loan. Persistence refers to your financial situation likely continuing for the term of the loan. To meet the good faith factor, the court wants to see that you made a strong effort to repay your student loan by attempting to find a workable payment plan.
Complete The Bankruptcy Forms
So far, everything in this guide on how to file bankruptcy in Missouri had to be done by you. You have to take the course, and you’re probably the only one that knows where your documents are. There is no way around that, not even if you hire a lawyer, find a pro bono lawyer, let Upsolve help you, or go at it completely alone. The next, most technical, step is where having someone guide you through the process, or doing the work for you can be helpful. In order to file a Chapter 7 bankruptcy in Missouri, you have to tell your story, but you have to use the official court forms to do it. It’s important to get the official court forms, even the local ones used only under Missouri bankruptcy laws, right, so your case goes smoothly and your discharge is entered without delay.
Read Also: What Is Epiq Bankruptcy Solutions Llc
Wipe Out Secured Debt
If you can’t afford a payment that you secured with collateralsuch as a mortgage or car loanyou can wipe out the debt in bankruptcy. But you won’t be able to keep the house, car, computer, or other item securing payment of the loan. When you voluntarily agree to secure debt with property, you must pay what you owe or give the property back .
Connect With A Diligent Attorney
A fresh start is available through bankruptcy. All you have to do is claim it. To begin the process, speak with a Missouri bankruptcy lawyer today.
Note: State laws are always subject to change through the passage of new legislation, rulings in the higher courts , ballot initiatives, and other means. While we strive to provide the most current information available, please consult an attorney or conduct your own legal research to verify the state law you are researching.
Don’t Miss: Has Mark Cuban Ever Filed For Bankruptcy
How Have Student Loan Bankruptcy Laws Changed In Recent Years
Not much has changed when it comes to private student loan bankruptcy law, but the interpretation of the law has definitely been relaxed.
In fact, in the past several years there have been many cases where private student loan debt was discharged via bankruptcy proceedings, and these cases are setting new precedents across the country, making it more likely that you could get approved for a bankruptcy discharge of your own.
Stories continue to emerge in the mainstream media proving that courts and judges across the country have been getting more lenient and allowing for more private student loan debt discharges than they had in the past, which is a great thing for those of you facing major financial trouble because of excessive debt.
So Before You Can Petition A Judge To Get Your Student Loans Discharged You Must File Chapter 7 Or Chapter 13 Bankruptcy
Can you file bankruptcy on student loans in missouri. Your attorney can help determine the type of consumer bankruptcy that s best for. And missouri non dischargeable debts back to top. The first is that student loans work just like credit cards.
In a chapter 13 case you can keep all of your property if your plan meets the requirements of the bankruptcy law. You must file for bankruptcy before your student loans can be discharged. Should you file for bankruptcy to discharge your student loans.
File for chapter 7 or 13 bankruptcy. Needless to say it s not entirely wrong to say if you can afford to fight this battle then you can afford to pay so you lose it is a catch 22 situation awaiting someday a solution. The second is that it is impossible to discharge student loan debt through bankruptcy.
If you get too far over your head you can declare bankruptcy and get a fresh start. You will complete extensive paperwork that requires you to disclose your. Kespohl mccrary cornejo llc 1103 east walnut street columbia mo 65201 573 443 2889.
If you are considering filing for a missouri bankruptcy you should educate yourself on federal and missouri bankruptcy laws. When you file for bankruptcy it can be costly and take. Chapter 7 bankruptcy usually results in a liquidation of your assets.
As you can see not all debt disappears after a bankruptcy so you should get advice from a professional before you file.
Pin By Exciting Blogs On Legal Blogs Recent News Attorney At
Recommended Reading: What Is Epiq Bankruptcy Solutions Llc
